timepiececlock: (Edward on drugs)
timepiececlock ([personal profile] timepiececlock) wrote2006-04-17 02:37 am
Entry tags:

(no subject)

I missed this the first time around. How did I miss it?

V. G. Cats is love, especially when they do an anime-mocking strip.


Funnily enough, the rant about IY being a rip-off version of Fushigi Yuugi is the exact same argument I gave after watching 15 episodes of Saiyuki: "It's FY, but with gay boys, and everyone is more annoying!"


That being linked, I actually liked IY enough to write some fic (especially the manga), but I stopped watching after around 80 episodes. Picked up a few here and there since then, but frankly I liked the first two seasons best. There was also my raging hate-on for Kikyo that reappeared every time she did.

I just could not.like. Kikyo after a while. At first she was an interesting villain, but then they tried to make her sympathize and I'm like, "Um, no. NO. Nobody who eats souls can get my sympathy, ever." Seeing as she kept eating souls, I kept wondering why Miroku and Sango didn't try to kill her every time they met. That's their fricking JOB. I can't buy into the idea that the heroes will eventually surmount any obstacle to beat any evil guy (it might take IY a while to boost his fighting levels, but such is anime) and then expect them to IGNORE the evil person right over there. For lord's sake, at least acknowledge that she's a soul-eating evil monster. IY is expected to be biased in this, but Kagome, Sango, Miroku, and Shippo know better.

And then, to my disappointment the writers/ Takeuchi didn't even keep her as a villain I could like (the way I love and hate Envy on FMA.) If they'd kept her evil (eating SOULS, hello?!) then at least she'd be more provocative. The more of the series I watched the more it seemed like they were trying to make Kikyo a different person from Kagome, an equally sympathetic person, which to me is a waste of the absolutely fascinating idea that Kagome is a reborn version of Kikyo-- Kikyo is Kagome, twisted and rotten inside but a part of Kagome's soul nonetheless. Think of how awesome that could have been, if they'd taken it further. Instead of trying to make me believe IY loves Kagome separately from Kikyo, why not run with the fact that he loves both of them? BECAUSE THEY'RE THE SAME PERSON. He falls in love with the same woman twice. If that's not proof of his love, I can't think of what would be. Instead of a Kagome/Kikyo/Inuyasha love triang/e, I'd rather have seen emphasis on [KagomeKikyo]/Inuyasha.


Wow. I totally didn't expect to sink into a ranty discussion right there. Huh. Guess I have lingering IY issues.

By the smelly hat of Gryffindor indeed.

[identity profile] akavertigo.livejournal.com 2006-04-17 09:54 am (UTC)(link)
Remember VG's FMA/Harry Potter duel? Heh. (My money was on the blond.)
ext_10182: Anzo-Berrega Desert (Default)

Re: By the smelly hat of Gryffindor indeed.

[identity profile] rashaka.livejournal.com 2006-04-17 09:57 am (UTC)(link)
That was great. I loved that one. This chapter of CC was actually inspired by that strip.

Re: By the smelly hat of Gryffindor indeed.

[identity profile] akavertigo.livejournal.com 2006-04-17 10:04 am (UTC)(link)
Carbon!
ext_10182: Anzo-Berrega Desert (Default)

Re: By the smelly hat of Gryffindor indeed.

[identity profile] rashaka.livejournal.com 2006-04-17 10:17 am (UTC)(link)
:D I've always been rather proud of "inbred mongrel serf" and "carbon-breath." The former because it's like saying "peasant" without saying "peasant", and the latter because Zuko might have really bad breath with all that firebreathing he does.

[identity profile] muffytaj.livejournal.com 2006-04-17 10:03 am (UTC)(link)
The whole Kikyo thing disgusted me too. I mean yes, it's sad that she died a horrible death when she was young, but that is no excuse for her to come back and eat everyone's souls! And then they were all "Aww, she heals kids! Isn't that nice?" but once the kids die SHE EATS THEIR SOULS. AND KILLS ANYONE WHO TRIES TO STOP HER. She is BAD. KILL HER. God all mighty, stop trying to insert love triangles into everything.

But then if I were Kagome I would have dumped Inuyasha's ass, and gone and found myself a real man. Demon. Whatever. Hell, Kouga only liked her because she could find jewel shards, and he was still nicer to her than Inuyasha.

Romance in that series was so messed up.
ext_10182: Anzo-Berrega Desert (Default)

[identity profile] rashaka.livejournal.com 2006-04-17 10:21 am (UTC)(link)
Yes to everything you just said about Kikyo. Yes. I just did not understand the fandom love for her. I'm more than willing to sympathize with villains, but they need to demonstrate somehow that they're on their way to not being villains anymore. This "I am totally sympathetic and pity-worthy, I'm so tragic, don't you just feel my woe and wish me a happy ending" stuff is crap when she says it with souls being sucked into her at the same time. Real people's</> souls, in a series where a "soul" is a legitimate concept of existence. Reincarnation (natural cycle) is unlikely if you're expired into nothing by Kikyo's consuming your energy.

I didn't mind Kagome/Inuyasha, as a pairing. But I could never be that girlfriend (IY is so not my type, though I liked his character a lot.)

[identity profile] donna-c-punk.livejournal.com 2006-04-18 02:37 am (UTC)(link)
IY? I feel I should know this title.
ext_10182: Anzo-Berrega Desert (Default)

[identity profile] rashaka.livejournal.com 2006-04-18 03:39 am (UTC)(link)
Inuyasha, dude.

You know that, you might not know you know it, but you do.

[identity profile] donna-c-punk.livejournal.com 2006-04-18 03:50 am (UTC)(link)
DUH. ::facepalm::

Okay.