this is only funny to myself.
Oct. 16th, 2003 08:04 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
timepiececlockSo I was arguing in the Harry/Ginny versus Harry/Luna debate thread at fictionalley.org, and complaining about Ginny's lack of character development as one of the reasons I don't ship her with Harry. I said basically that she has no defining personality, not like the other characters in the books do.
Anyway, someone said this in response:
"I guess you don't have a strong opinion of JKR's abilities, Rashaka. She's been developed in great detail."
I started laughing out loud at my computer, despite my recent sicknesss/couging today. I couldn't help it. I wanted really badly to retort "No, point of fact I don't, but you don't want to get me started on that, and I don't think it's part of the Ginny developement issue anyway."
I'm not going to say it though. Because they'd jump on me if I said "You know, I enjoy the books too, but face reality folks she still only a mediocre beginner writer."
Definitely, definitely not going to say that.
It occurs to me that for HP fandom I'm the equivalent of the people who watched every season 7 Buffy episode even though they hated it, and spent all their time bitching about the glory days and fighting over ships/characters "gone astray" and how quality was lost... except without the glory days part.
Am I the only person in HP fandom who likes the characters and storyline and mildly enjoys the books, but who doesn't praise JKRowling to the point of Josshood? Because I really, really don't. In fact, the idea makes me giggle with disbelief.
Anyway, someone said this in response:
"I guess you don't have a strong opinion of JKR's abilities, Rashaka. She's been developed in great detail."
I started laughing out loud at my computer, despite my recent sicknesss/couging today. I couldn't help it. I wanted really badly to retort "No, point of fact I don't, but you don't want to get me started on that, and I don't think it's part of the Ginny developement issue anyway."
I'm not going to say it though. Because they'd jump on me if I said "You know, I enjoy the books too, but face reality folks she still only a mediocre beginner writer."
Definitely, definitely not going to say that.
It occurs to me that for HP fandom I'm the equivalent of the people who watched every season 7 Buffy episode even though they hated it, and spent all their time bitching about the glory days and fighting over ships/characters "gone astray" and how quality was lost... except without the glory days part.
Am I the only person in HP fandom who likes the characters and storyline and mildly enjoys the books, but who doesn't praise JKRowling to the point of Josshood? Because I really, really don't. In fact, the idea makes me giggle with disbelief.
![[identity profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/openid.png){kind=small}
no subject
Date: 2003-10-17 06:16 pm (UTC)Interesting point.
Her ideas, I'm sure, must be good - which is more of the 'talent' portion of writing.
Oh, she's got plenty of great ideas. One of the reasons I've gotten so far in these books (I actually... ::gasp::...purchased book 5) is that she doesn't lack in imagination or creativity. But sometimes it's made awkward because her skill level hasn't caught up with her imagination level.
She won't let people edit her books anymore. Just like Anne Rice.
Ugh, really? I tried to read The Witching Hour once, by Anne Rice, and I couldn't get through it. I got bored with all the incest, and the very stupid female protagonist. And it was so freaking drawn out...
thanks for you opinion. I've glad you've started to comment on my journal; your opinions are nice to hear. :)